Wales win fight for Shingler
March 8, 2012
Steven Shingler will not be allowed to play for Scotland © Getty Images
London Irish centre Steven Shingler is tied to Wales and ineligible to play for Scotland, the International Rugby Board have announced.
The 20-year-old fly-half or centre was included in Scotland head coach Andy Robinson's provisional squad for the Six Nations, sparking an investigation into his eligibility. The Scottish Rugby Union believed Shingler qualified through his Dumfries-born mother.
However, the Welsh Rugby Union contended Shingler was tied to them having played for their Under-20s side against France in 2011. And now the IRB have ruled Shingler is eligible only for Wales.
An initial informal assessment by the IRB determined that the player appeared to be tied to Wales and the SRU formally requested the IRB regulations committee to review the case.
A three-man regulations committee panel chaired by Peter Boyle (Ireland) and also comprising Giancarlo Dondi (Italy) and Tim Gresson (New Zealand) heard evidence from Shingler, his agent and the Scottish and Welsh Rugby Unions at a hearing in Dublin on February 27 before announcing their verdict.
A statement from the IRB read: "The IRB regulations committee panel hearing the Steven Shingler eligibility case has determined that the player is tied to Wales in accordance with IRB regulation eight as it stands and therefore is ineligible to represent another Union.
"The panel determined that, based on the relevant provisions of IRB regulation eight, the relevant guidelines and the facts presented at the hearing, Shingler is captured for Wales in accordance with IRB regulation eight.
"This decision is binding on the parties until it is endorsed or overturned by the IRB council.
"The panel noted that, in accordance with IRB regulation eight, playing in a designated capturing match was the key determining factor with regard to the player's eligibility.
"In this respect the panel accepted the evidence of the Welsh Rugby Union that although Shingler had not signed the Union eligibility confirmation form he had been fully advised by the WRU that playing in the France Under-20 v Wales Under-20 match during the 2011 Under-20 Six Nations would capture him for Wales."
The SRU responded in a statement, which read: "Scottish Rugby notes the decision of the IRB Regulations Committee hearing the Steven Shingler eligibility case.
"We remain fully supportive of Steven Shingler, a talented young rugby player, who has expressed his sincere and earnest wish to represent Scotland. We await the full written decision of the IRB Regulations Committee and may comment further on receipt."
The IRB council can overturn decisions by the regulations committee and though any new law would not be applied retroactively, Shingler's case arose during the review on eligibility launched in April 2011 - meaning it is feasible, though unlikely, they could reopen the door for him to represent Scotland.
© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.
"The real problem rugby faces is the concussion tests in place can be manipulated by the players." Part two of Rory Lamont on concussion. Part one is here
"The Lions is a meritocracy, pure and simple." The Crooked Feed gives its view on Gatland's call for a Lions quota system
The latest Week in Pictures brings you a selection of the best snaps from around the rugby world with a topless Carlin Isles and scantily clad Waratahs players featuring
"There is a duty to ensure that every person who decides to participate in rugby has an understanding of the possible lasting effects of concussion." Rory Lamont tells his story