All Blacks coaches, Bill McLaren's Scotland trial and 'The Best Player of all time'
December 20, 2011
Bill McLaren's trial for Scotland comes into question in this edition of 'Ask John' © Getty Images
Welcome to the latest edition of Ask John where renowned rugby historian John Griffiths will answer any rugby-related query you have!
So, if there's something you've always wanted to know about the game we love but didn't know who to ask, or you think you can stump our expert - then get involved by sending us a question.
In this edition, John Griffiths looks at the best All Blacks Test coaches of the professional era, Bill McLaren's Scotland trial, the first Welsh referee in French club matches, fickle half-back selection and 'the best player of all time.'
Graham Henry's winning percentage with the All Blacks is in the mid-80s and seems phenomenally good. How does that compare with other coaches who have had tenures lasting at least a couple of seasons since the game became professional?James Tipping, New Zealand
All four NZ Test head-coaches of the professional era have had 75% (or better) Test records:
Among others who had tenures lasting for at least two years, only Rod Macqueen for Australia can boast a Test record approaching Mitchell and Henry's. He steered the Wallabies through 43 Tests between November 1997 and July 2001 before standing down after the series with the Lions.
Australia won 34 and drew one of his Tests - an 80% success record. During his stewardship Australia won the World Cup, took a series off the Lions and never had to hand the Bledisloe Cup to New Zealand.
Sir Clive Woodward (like his predecessors Geoff Cooke and Jack Rowell before the start of the professional era) had 72% records as England's head coach/manager and Nick Mallett's record with South Africa (1997 to 2000) was 71%.
Can you provide any details of the late Bill McLaren's Final trial for Scotland? Andy Ross, New Zealand
The distinguished BBC commentator played from the Hawick club for the Rest against Scotland in the Final trial of the 1947-48 season. The trial was staged at Murrayfield on Saturday 20th December, 1947, and Bill played in the back-row for a side that upside the form-book by winning 8-0.
Scotland, however, were well-served by top-class back-row forwards at this time and the senior side's back-row of Elliot, Watt and Lees retained their places for the opening match of the Five Nations season against France a month later.
For the record, the details of Bill's Final Trial are as follows:
Scotland 0, The Rest 8 (1G 1T) at Murrayfield, December 20th, 1947
Scotland: I J M Lumsden; T G H Jackson, J R S Innes (captain), E Ogilvie, D D Mackenzie; K D Buchanan, W D Allardice; R M Bruce, G G Lyall, I C Henderson, L Currie, J C Dawson, W I D Elliot, A G M Watt, J B Lees
The Rest of Scotland: D McIntyre; R W G Jarvie, L Gloag, A D Cameron, C R W Andrew; Angus Cameron, A W Black; W D F Stobie, R W Pringle, S Coltman, R Gemmill, H H Campbell, D Gibson, W P Black, W P McLaren Scorers Tries: Pringle, Todd Conversion: Andrew
The fly-halves (Buchanan and Angus Cameron) and the centres (Gloag and Ogilvie) swapped sides after half-time. W A Todd of Bath came into the Rest back-row to replace Bill McLaren at the interval. The rugby correspondent of The Glasgow Herald, unsure as to why McLaren had been substituted, reported: "the Borderer's departure could not have arisen from his display."
Who was the first Welsh referee to control a French club match? Geoff James, Wales
It was common for Home Unions referees to take charge of French home Tests and friendly matches involving French clubs against visiting English-speaking teams as long ago as the years before the Great War.
The first Welshman to control a match between French clubs is thought to have been Trevor Jones of Maesteg. He took charge of the England-France international at Twickenham in 1947 - France's first Test at Twickenham for 17 years - and a few months later was invited to take control of the New Year's Day (1948) game between Nantes and Pau.
Was there ever a Five Nations tournament where one of the countries used different half-backs for every match? If not, what was the closest any team came? Graham Smith, England
The French used to be notorious for fickle selections but only once - in 1926 - did they call on seven different players (out of a maximum eight) to fill the fly-half and scrum-half roles in the old Five Nations. The only player who made two half-back appearances for them that season was Vincent Graule at fly-half. They used four different scrum-halves in their four games.
Even so, that only equalled the Championship record: Wales had also used seven for their Five Nations campaign in 1921.
Wales opened the season at Twickenham with Jack Wetter and Fred Reeves as their halves, recalled Tommy Vile (17 years since making his Test debut on the 1904 Lions tour and eight years since his last match for Wales) to partner new cap Willie Bowen against Scotland and retained Bowen to play with his Swansea club partner Tudor Williams against France. Finally, the Welsh selection committee turned to Clem Lewis and Archie Brown for the match in Belfast in March.
Who is the best player of all time and why? Joshua Peleti, Australia
How long is a piece of string?
It is impossible of course to compare across the generations - different physiques, different laws and the change from an amateur sport to one that is fully professional at Test level complicate the issue.
Most would probably agree with a shortlist that includes Arthur Gould, Billy Bancroft, David Gallaher, Dickie Owen and Ronnie Poulton pre-Great war; Wavell Wakefield, "Dave" Davies, George Nepia, Maurice Brownlie, Wilf Wooller, Cliff Jones, Bennie Osler and Danie Craven between the Wars; and Cliff Morgan, Bleddyn Williams, Jean Prat, Jack Kyle, Hennie Muller, Lucien Mias, Frik du Preez, Colin Meads and Wilson Whineray up to the introduction of the restriction on kicking to touch in 1968.
Between then and the professional era the claims of Mike Gibson, Barry John, Gerald Davies, Gareth Edwards, Sid Going, J P R Williams, Andy Irvine, Serge Blanco, David Campese, Philippe Sella, Grant Fox and Rory Underwood would feature prominently, while of recent vintage the likes of Jason Leonard, Jonah Lomu, John Eales, Martin Johnson, Jonny Wilkinson and Richie McCaw would warrant serious consideration.
Statistically speaking there are several players (mostly one-cap merchants) who have 100% Test winning records - an objective criterion perhaps for answering this question. One player stands out, moreover, for playing on a winning side and scoring the winning points. His name is Denzil Thomas, the Neath and Llanelli fly-half-cum-centre who had a penchant for dropped goals. He played for Wales against Ireland at Lansdowne Road in 1954.
In his only Test appearance he scored Wales's winning points with a very late dropped goal. The scores were tied at 9-all with Wales attacking in the game's dying moments. Then, according to the veteran rugby writer Dai Gent of the Sunday Times, "Denzil Thomas kicked his goal, cleverly wriggling his way to get the opportunity."
It was Thomas's misfortune to be a Welsh centre at the same time as Bleddyn Williams, Malcolm Thomas, Gareth Griffiths, Glyn John and Alun Thomas. Had it not been for their presence, the man the Neath and Llanelli faithful nicknamed "Denzil Drop" would have won many more Welsh caps.
He was later a popular schoolmaster in South and West Wales. Max Wiltshire and Jim Shanklin were among the Welsh international players he nurtured while another former pupil, Brian Diment, emulated his master by dropping a goal for Swansea in their 9-8 victory over the 1966 Wallabies.
© ESPN EMEA Ltd
"People on the outside think unfounded thoughts on Toulon." Tom Hamilton talks to RCT lock Nick Kennedy ahead of Saturday's Heineken Cup final against Clermont
Will Genia should lead the Wallabies against the Lions, Joe Tomane to win the final wing spot and Israel Folau at fullback, writes Greg Growden
"Has there ever been such a large disconnect between France's club teams and the international side?" Ian Moriarty weighs up the state of French rugby
"By carrying a Great Britain label to the Antipodes, and getting beaten by the Kiwis, they established a tradition which has lasted to this day." Huw Richards rewinds to 1888