Munster survive Montauban scare
October 10, 2008
Munster's Paul O'Connell earns some hard yards
© Getty Images
Heineken Cup holders Munster began their defence of the title with a tentative 19-17 victory over Montauban at Thomond Park.
Munster required a 78th-minute penalty from Ronan O'Gara to end Montauban's stubborn resistance and avoid what would have been one of the biggest shocks in Heineken Cup history.
In the pre-match build-up, new coach Tony McGahan admitted that Munster would be gunning for all five points in their Pool 1 opener, but all talk of bonus points quickly evaporated at a shell-shocked Thomond Park. The defending champions trailed on three separate occasions at their new stadium, with Romanian scrum half Petre Mitu's fourth penalty success putting Montauban within three-and-a-half minutes of a famous win.
But O'Gara, the tournament's record points scorer, rained on the visitors' parade when he slotted that late kick to save his side's bacon and finally soothe the nervy home crowd. Montauban, the 55th club to grace Europe's premier competition, travelled north with a largely second string line-up, making 10 changes to the team that lost 34-16 to Stade Francais last weekend.
And while Munster fielded their strongest possible side, their intentions to thrill all at their redeveloped Limerick home, coupled with Montauban's rugged defending, made for an error-ridden first half. The nuggety Mitu kicked well behind an industrious pack, in which English number eight Matthew Clarkin carried and harried with purpose.
His France-capped back row colleagues Yannick Caballero and Marc Raynaud stood out too, as Munster grew frustrated by their lack of accuracy and momentum.
They paid for their over-eagerness with five handling errors in the opening quarter - nerves getting the better of Heineken Cup debutant Keith Earls on a couple of occasions. Montauban edged ahead in the sixth minute when Mitu, not a regular goal-kicker in the Top 14, landed a penalty from distance.
Munster struggled to get to grips with referee Wayne Barnes' interpretation and were forcing things as Montauban fanned out and soaked up the pressure. Mitu missed his second shot at the posts and Munster upped the tempo before half-time, levelling first through an O'Gara penalty before replacement Barry Murphy muscled over for a relieving try.
Finding some space on the right, Murphy stepped inside two defenders before crashing over and after confirmation from TMO Graham Hughes, O'Gara's conversion put the hosts 10-3 ahead for the break. Unbeaten in the Magners League, Munster looked primed to canter away from Montauban in the second half.
But maintaining their poise, Raynaud and his team-mates continued to play intelligently and suck the life out of the champions, spoiling superbly and creating chances for Mitu. The number nine was successful with two out of his three shots at the posts, coming up to the hour mark, allowing Montauban to stay competitive and within four points (13-9).
At the other end, O'Gara had bisected the posts after Paul O'Connell was held up short, but the prospect of Montauban becoming only the second team to win a European tie at Thomond Park grew with a 57th-minute try. Alan Quinlan's suicidal pass, close to the halfway line, bounced forward off Rida Jahouer's head and winger Sylvain Jonnet hared up to hack on the loose ball and beat David Wallace to the touchdown.
Mitu failed to convert and missed kicks eventually cost Laurent Labit's charges, despite O'Gara pinging a 61st-minute effort off the post. In a nail-biting finish, Munster's greater experience saw them survive as a composed O'Gara kicked two timely penalties, taking his tally to 14 points and cruelly bringing Montauban back down to earth.
Munster: Earls, Howlett, Tipoki, Mafi, Dowling, O'Gara, Stringer, Horan, Flannery, Hayes, O'Connell, O'Callaghan, Quinlan, Wallace, Melck.
Replacements: Murphy for Tipoki (37), Warwick for Dowling (53), Pucciariello for Hayes (65), Ryan for Quinlan (62), O'Sullivan for Melck (70).
Not Used: Fogarty, Prendergast.
Montauban: Dalla Riva, Jonnet, Viard, Jaouher, Cassin, Lespinas, Mitu, Balan, Mach, Adams, Murray, Frost, Caballero, Raynaud, Clarkin.
Replacements: Laharrague for Jonnet (73), Del Boulbes for Balan (67), Traversa for Mach (80), Florea for Adams (72), Ghezal for Frost (65), Battut for Clarkin (69).
Not Used: Fortassin.
Heineken Man of the Match: P Mitu (Montauban)
Ref: Wayne Barnes (England).
Last year's thrashing at the hands of Wales was not the first time England have fallen to their rivals. Scrum Sevens looks at whether they have bounced back the following year
With just two rounds left in the 2014 championship, the intensity cranks up a notch at Twickenham. Tom Hamilton previews the weekend's action
"I had a perfect record against England as did a few other Welshmen. England always seemed to bring the best out of us." John Taylor on the age-old rivalry
Are the margins between the teams in the Six Nations getting smaller year-on-year? Huw Richards gives some answers