Pulver to ask for change to "unfair" appeal process
July 3, 2013
James Horwill cut a much different figure after the appeal decision on Tuesday © Getty Images
Wallabies officials are demanding a review of the legal process that left captain James Horwill "in complete and utter mental disarray", disrupting Australia's preparations for the series-deciding third Lions Test.
Australia Rugby Union (ARU) chief executive Bill Pulver accused the IRB of overseeing a lengthy procedure that was at the very least "problematic".
"I simply have a problem with the double-jeopardy concept of being tried twice for essentially the same issue," Pulver said. "I'll be writing the IRB. In fairness to the IRB they've operated well within the laws as defined, I just think it needs to be reviewed and I would like to see it changed."
Horwill was cleared of foul play for allegedly stamping on the head of Lions lock Alun Wyn Jones, which would have ruled him out of Saturday's series decider against the British & Irish Lions in Sydney.
The skipper, who shed tears after last weekend's 16-15 win over the tourists, had already been cleared once by a judicial officer the day after losing the first Test in Brisbane on June 22. But he took the field for the second Test in Melbourne under a cloud, with the IRB challenging his acquittal in an unprecedented appeal.
Pulver said he was "uncomfortable with the process around that judicial review", describing the lengthy period between the initial allegation of stamping and Horwill's ultimate acquittal as "unacceptable leading into a Test match".
James Horwill "vindicated" after being cleared of stamping charge for a second time
Independent appeal officer Graeme Mew dismissed the IRB challenge after a two-and-a-half-hour videoconference hearing from Toronto and nearly 12 hours of deliberation. Canadian arbitrator Mew upheld the original decision, saying there had been "no misapprehension of law or principle" proven and no evidence that the [first] acquittal was unreasonable.
Mew said the IRB appeal had been appropriate to safeguard player welfare and protect rugby's image and reputation. But Pulver said the "drawn-out saga" had left Horwill "in complete and utter mental disarray".
"Proof of that was the image of James on his knees at the end of the [second Test] match," he said. "The process is inappropriate, and the trauma and anxiety it caused the player is completely unfair."
Horwill put on a brave face on Tuesday, saying: "I feel very vindicated by the way that it's gone." He called both hearings "incredibly fair and thorough".
The ARU noted that the IRB had never before intervened to overturn a not guilty verdict against a player. Australia's Rugby Union Players' Association (RUPA) welcomed the ruling, saying it had been surprised and disappointed at the IRB's appeal, which it described as a "dangerous precedent" with questionable motives.
A unanimous vote at the IRB council a year ago gave the governing body the right to appeal decisions made by disciplinary hearings.
© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.
"The fairytale continued right to the end for the magic man." Tom Hamilton reports on the game that saw Brian O'Driscoll bid adieu with the Six Nations title
"It is a sign of how far this England team have come that they looked disappointed at the full-time whistle having just put 52 points on Italy." Tom Hamilton writes
We bring together a selection of the best pictures from the final round of the Six Nations and one which ended in Irish victory
"Some people have it from day one and Brian did." Tom Hamilton talks to the two players who made their Ireland debuts alongside Brian O'Driscoll back in June 1999