Miscellaneous Welsh rugby queries and most pupils from one school in a Test 15
January 2, 2012
Barry John, in action here for the British and Irish Lions, scored Wales' last three-point try © Getty Images
Phil Bennett Roy Bergiers Gerald Davies Mervyn Davies John Dawes Geoff Evans Ray Gravell Hefin Jenkins Roy Mathias John Taylor Delme Thomas JPR Williams
Welcome to the latest edition of Ask John where renowned rugby historian John Griffiths will answer any rugby-related query you have!
So, if there's something you've always wanted to know about the game we love but didn't know who to ask, or you think you can stump our expert - then get involved by sending us a question.
In this edition, John Griffiths addresses a number of Welsh rugby-related questions, as well as the Test side with the most graduates from the same school.
With club rugby in full swing I decided to look through my old Rothmans Rugby Union Yearbooks. I noticed that Wales had two championships in operation prior to the introduction of formal Leagues. When was the Merit Table introduced and who were Wales's pre-war winners of the club championship? James Hothersall, Australia
The Welsh Leagues were officially launched in September 1990.
Before that the Welsh Championship was an unofficial ranking of the first-class Welsh clubs based on their average record across all official matches played during the season. The Merit table, the second of the classifications you refer to, was restricted to results among Welsh clubs.
For both systems, each match a first-class club played carried two points for a win, one for a draw and none for a loss. The average (actually a percentage) was the measure of a club's success over the season. The club with the best average was declared unofficial Welsh champion for the season.
The Championship Table had appeared regularly in the Western Mail, Wales's national newspaper, since before the Great War. It should be pointed out, however, that the table was to some extent misleading because the clubs had fixture lists of varying strengths. This was particularly true with respect to meetings with English opponents. As a result, the clubs who did not meet the Bristols, Leicesters and Northamptons etc home and/or away were not subjected to such varied or demanding tests.
The objectivity of the exercise also depended on the accuracy and completeness of the records available. From 1946 to the introduction of the Welsh Leagues the unsung hero who kept reliable records for the Western Mail was their staffman, John Billot, for whom the exercise was a labour of love.
The phrase "Welsh Merit Table" filtering the results among the first-class Welsh clubs appeared around forty to fifty years ago but was not a new idea. The Western Mail had produced separate tables - the so-called Championship Table and their own All-Welsh Table - between the wars. Their method included only the results of matches that had been listed in the fixtures section of the WRU's official handbook for the season.
The Rothmans Rugby Yearbooks and before them the Playfair Rugby Annuals listed the post-war seasonal records of the Welsh clubs. Before the War, rugby's "bible" was the Rugby Football Annual which ran from 1913 to 1939, though for three years (1923-24 to 1925-26) Wisden, the publishers of the famous cricketers' almanac, also produced expansive tomes devoted to rugby.
Based on the playing records given in these publications the winners of Wales's unofficial Championship between the Wars were as follows:
Some sources give Cardiff (1924-25), Newport (1927-28) and Llanelli (1933-34) slightly better playing records than the champions listed above. Aberavon, moreover, finished above Neath in 1934-35 in the All-Welsh table based on matches in which Welsh clubs met each other.
A further complication that should be noted is that between 1926 and 1931 there were five seasons when Cardiff fielded two "first" fifteens. It was the norm for publications to consolidate the results for the club's two teams.
Can you tell me who scored Wales' last three-point try and first four-point try in Tests, from memory I thought it maybe Phil Bennett and JPR. And who scored Wales' last four-point try and first five-point try? Ray, United Kingdom
The value of a try was raised from three to four points at the start of the 1971-72 season. The last three-point try for Wales was scored by Barry John against France in Paris in March 1971. Wales won 9-5 and completed their first Grand Slam since 1952. J P R Williams scored their first four-pointer crossing at Twickenham in January 1972 in a 12-3 win for Wales.
The try was upgraded to five points in mid-1992. Richard Webster scored the last four-pointer in Wales's 15-12 win against Scotland at Cardiff in March 1992. Ieuan Evans's match-winner in the 10-9 victory over Will Carling's reigning Grand Slam champions in February 1993 was Wales's first five-point Test try.
It was also the first five-pointer to "make a difference" to the outcome of a Test match - the game would have been left drawn at 9-all under the previous scoring system.
When did Wales ditch their A team? Stephen Williams, Wales
The WRU ditched the A team as a cost-saving measure after the 2002 A-Six Nations tournament.
The old Five Nations had operated a full A-team competition in the late 1990s and the A teams participated in a full shadow Six Nations tournament for a couple of seasons after Italy joined the fray in 2000.
Do you have details of the 1971 Boxing Day match between Llanelli and London Welsh which I believe was regarded as an extra Welsh trial? D Thomas, Wales
The traditional Boxing Day fixture was a big attraction in West Wales in the years before the game went professional and the matches of the early 1970s, when the clubs provided the nucleus of the Wales (and 1971 Lions) teams, were a great draw.
The 1971 match was played on Monday 27th December and London Welsh fielded a dozen Welsh internationals, including six members of the triumphant 1971 Lions tour side to New Zealand. As you say, the Welsh selectors (the Big Five) were in attendance.
The day was damp and overcast but by the time the match started under floodlights Stradey Park was bursting at the seams. The sides produced a wonderfully entertaining match with the Scarlets running out 20-10 winners.
Llanelli made frequent use of their young strong-running centre, Ray Gravell, early on and a pick-up from a five-yards scrum by Hefin Jenkins led to Gravell opening the scoring with a try that Andy Hill converted. A break by John Dawes led to a penalty kicked by J P R Williams before Mervyn Davies, standing off at a scrum, set up a movement that resulted in Keith Hughes crossing under the posts. J P R Williams failed with the easy kick, but the exiles held on to lead 7-6 at the interval.
Llanelli regained the lead when Phil Bennett worked an opening for Roy Mathias to score, Hill converting, and further tries by Gravell and fullback Roger Davies gave the Scarlets an unassailable 20-7 lead. London Welsh put together a series of exciting attacks in the closing ten minutes but their only reward was a penalty goal kicked by John Taylor.
The teams were:
Llanelli: R Davies; A Hill, R T E Bergiers, R W R Gravell, R Mathias; P Bennett, S Williams; D B Llewelyn (captain), M Davies, C Charles, D L Quinnell, W D Thomas, J Vaughan, H Jenkins, A James
L Welsh: J P R Williams; T G R Davies, S J Dawes, K S Hughes, J L Shanklin; R H Phillips, W G Hullin; F Williams, D Ford, I C Jones, J James, T G Evans, A J Gray (captain), T M Davies, J Taylor Referee : M Davies (WRU)
Eight of the Boxing Day "trialists" featured when the Welsh selectors convened a couple of weeks later to name the side for the Five Nations opener against England at Twickenham: J P R Williams, Gerald Davies, Roy Bergiers, Barrie Llewelyn, Geoff Evans, Delme Thomas, Mervyn Davies and John Taylor.
What is the largest cohort of former pupils from one school in a Test team? Graham Smith, England
Rugby School (not surprisingly) provided ten pupils for the English team that lost to Scotland at Raeburn Place, Edinburgh, in March 1871 in the first-ever rugby international.
The Old Rugbeians in the England side were: F Stokes (captain), A G Guillemard, A Lyon, J F Green, F Tobin, J H Clayton, A Davenport, J M Dugdale, C W Sherrard and D P Turner.
© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.
In the wake of another perfect November series, Monday Maul talks to NZRU CEO Steve Tew about the constant demand for perfection
The latest Week in Pictures takes in all the action from the weekend when rugby united behind Samoa
The Wallabies showed flair in Dublin, but they still have a way to go if they are to do more than make up the numbers at the World Cup, writes Greg Growden
England broke their losing streak, but this was not them clawing their way back among the best, writes Tom Hamilton